Appeals
This page lists the appeals submitted to the IESG as part of the IETF standards process and any replies by the IESG.
The process for appealing decisions made as part of the IETF process is described in section 6.5 of RFC 2026. The IESG Statement "On Appeals of IESG and Area Director Actions and Decisions" re-affirms this process.
- Appeal re: URI Scheme Application and draft-mcsweeney-drop-scheme (Tim McSweeney, 2020-07-08) / IESG Response (PDF)
- Appeal to the IESG re WGLC of draft-ietf-spring-srv6-network-programming (Fernando Gont, Andrew Alston, and Sander Steffann, 2020-04-22) / IESG Response
- Appeal re Protocol Action: 'URI Design and Ownership' to Best
Current Practice (draft-nottingham-rfc7320bis-03.txt) (John Klensin; 2020-02-04) / IESG Response
- Appeal of IESG Conflict Review process and decision on draft-mavrogiannopoulos-pkcs8-validated-parameters-02 (John Klensin; 2018-07-07) / IESG Response
- Appeal of IESG decision to defer action and request that ISE publish draft-klensin-dns-function-considerations (John Klensin; 2017-11-29) / IESG Response
- Appeal to the IESG concerning its approval of the "draft-ietf-ianaplan-icg-response" (PDF file) (JFC Morfin; 2015-03-11) / IESG Response
- Appeal re tzdist mailing list moderation (Tobias Conradi; 2014-08-28) / Withdrawn by Submitter
- Appeal re draft-masotta-tftpexts-windowsize-opt (Patrick Masotta; 2013-11-14) / IESG Response
- Appeal re draft-ietf-manet-nhdp-sec-threats (Abdussalam Baryun; 2013-06-19) / IESG Response
- Appeal of decision to advance RFC6376 (Douglas Otis; 2013-05-30) / IESG Response
- Appeal to the IESG in regards to RFC 6852 (PDF file) (JFC Morfin; 2013-04-05) / IESG Response
- Appeal to the IESG concerning the approbation of the IDNA2008 document set (PDF file) (JFC Morfin; 2010-03-10) / IESG Response
- Authentication-Results Header Field Appeal (Douglas Otis, David Rand; 2009-02-16) / Withdrawn by Submitter
- Appeal to the IAB of IESG rejection of Appeal to Last Call draft-ietf-grow-anycast (Dean Anderson; 2008-11-14) / IESG Response
- Appeal to the IESG Concerning the Way At Large Internet Lead Users Are Not Permitted To Adequately Contribute to the IETF Deliverables (JFC Morfin; 2008-09-10) / IESG Response
- Appeal over suspension of posting rights for Todd Glassey (Todd Glassey; 2008-07-28) / IESG Response
- Appeal against IESG blocking DISCUSS on draft-klensin-rfc2821bis (John C Klensin; 2008-06-13) / IESG Response
- Appeal: Continued Abuse of Process by IPR-WG Chair (Dean Anderson; 2007-12-26) / IESG Response
- Appeal to the IESG from Todd Glassey (Todd Glassey; 2007-11-26) / IESG Response
- Appeal Against the Removal of the Co-Chairs of the GEOPRIV Working Group (PDF file) (Randall Gellens, Allison Mankin, and Andrew Newton; 2007-06-22) / IESG Response
- Appeal concerning the WG-LTRU rechartering (JFC Morfin; 2006-10-24) / IESG Response
- Appeal against decision within July 10 IESG appeal dismissal (JFC Morfin; 2006-09-09) / IESG Response
- Appeal: Mandatory to implement HTTP authentication mechanism in the Atom Publishing Protocol (Robert Sayre; 2006-08-29) / IESG Response
- Appeal Against IESG Decisions Regarding the draft-ietf-ltru-matching (PDF file) (JFC Morfin; 2006-08-16) / IESG Response (Part 1)(Part 2)
- Amended Appeal Re: grow: Last Call: 'Operation of Anycast Services' to BCP (draft-ietf-grow-anycast) (Dean Anderson; 2006-06-14) / IESG Response
- Appeal Against an IESG Decision Denying Me IANA Language Registration Process by way of PR-Action (PDF file) (JFC Morfin; 2006-05-17) / IESG Response
- Appeal to the IESG of PR-Action against Dean Anderson (Dean Anderson; 2006-03-08) / IESG Response
- Appeal to IESG against AD decision: one must clear the confusion opposing the RFC 3066 Bis consensus (JFC Morfin; 2006-02-20) / IESG Response
- Appeal to the IESG of an IESG decision (JFC Morfin; 2006-02-17) / IESG Response
- Appeal to the IESG in reference to the ietf-languages@alvestrand.no mailing list (JFC Morfin; 2006-02-07) / IESG Response
- Appeal to the IESG against an IESG decision concerning RFC 3066 Bis Draft (JFC Morfin; 2006-01-14) / IESG Response
- Appeal over a key change in a poor RFC 3066 bis example (JFC Morfin; 2005-10-19) / IESG Response
- Additional appeal against publication of draft-lyon-senderid-* in regards to its recommended use of Resent- header fields in the way that is inconsistant with RFC2822(William Leibzon; 2005-08-29) / IESG Response
- Appeal: Publication of draft-lyon-senderid-core-01 in conflict with referenced draft-schlitt-spf-classic-02 (Julian Mehnle; 2005-08-25) / IESG Response
- Appeal of decision to standardize "Mapping Between the Multimedia Messaging Service (MMS) and Internet Mail" (John C Klensin; 2005-06-10) / IESG Response
- Appeal regarding IESG decision on the GROW WG (David Meyer; 2003-11-15) / IESG Response
- Appeal: Official notice of appeal on suspension rights (Todd Glassey; 2003-08-06) / IESG Response
- Appeal: AD response to Site-Local Appeal (Tony Hain; 2003-07-31) / IESG Response
- Appeal against IESG decision for draft-chiba-radius-dynamic-authorization-05.txt (Glen Zorn; 2003-01-15) / IESG Response
- Appeal Against moving draft-ietf-ipngwg-addr-arch-v3 to Draft Standard (Robert Elz; 2002-11-05) / IESG Response